News from the world of higher education
Stäng denna sökruta.
News from the world of higher education
Stäng denna sökruta.
This content comes from our previous website and may therefore look different. We ask for your indulgence on this.

Researcher wants to see changes to the Ethical Review Act

The way the Ethical Review Act is designed leads to great waste of researchers' time and resources. There is also a danger that potentially important research is not conducted, says doctoral candidate August Danielson.

Linus Hellerstedt
Doctoral candidate August Danielson has compared the ethical review process in Sweden with the rest of the EU. He notes that the design of the Swedish Ethical Review Act leads to considerable waste of researchers' time and resources.

The idea that ethical review is a threat to academic freedom was the starting point for a seminar organised by SULF and Young Academy of Sweden.

Sweden stands out
The seminar was led by August Danielson, a doctoral candidate in political science at Uppsala University, who has examined ethical review in a number of EU member states. And Sweden stands out. “For example with regard to legal requirements for ethical review of non-medical research. This is something that other EU member states don’t have,” he tells Universitetsläraren.

August Danielson Foto: Mikael Wallerstedt

In the rest of the EU, the norm is that ethical review of humanities research about people is conducted instead by the higher education institutions’ own committees, explains Danielson, whose own research is on the work of diplomats.

Well-known case in Örebro
One reason why he became interested in ethical review was the case of a doctoral candidate in Örebro, whose thesis defence was cancelled when they were reported to the Ethics Review Appeals Board (Önep). Universitetsläraren has written about this case previously.

The more he read up on the legislation, the clearer it became that there is not enough knowledge about where the boundaries lie regarding what research falls under the Ethical Review Act and what does not. Both at his own and other political science departments.

When researchers are unsure of the law and therefore apply for ethical review in case it is required, this is not only a waste of resources and time, says Danielson. “In short, people may simply refrain from doing important research simply because they want to avoid the ethical review process. That is a huge problem.”

Worried about prosecution
Uncertainty about what rules apply causes researchers to worry about being prosecuted. “This may be for various reasons,” he says, “but above all it could be that they are not entirely sure about a rather complicated piece of legislation and how that legislation is applied. The risk of making unintentional mistakes is enormous.”

His study resulted in various proposals. One is to amend the Ethical Review Act so that Önep does not need bring charges for minor breaches such as careless mistakes or failure to apply for ethical approval before commencing research.

Proposed exemptions
Changing the law so that a consent from the research subject exempts the research from the provisions of the Ethical Review Act is another option, which is similar to the Finnish system. A further proposal is to exempt non-medical research from ethical review altogether.

“That might sound extremely controversial from a Swedish perspective, but that is how it works in many other countries,” says August Danielson.

Linus Hellerstedt


The Swedish Ethical Review Authority examines applications for ethical review through its 21 departments, with 16 members in each. An application for ethical review costs SEK 5,000.


The Ethics Review Appeals Board (Önep) hears appeals against decisions by the Ethical Review Authority and exercises supervision. Since 2020, Önep has charged 19 researchers for suspected violations of the Ethical Review Act.

Universitetsläraren conforms strictly to journalistic principles and follows the media industry’s rules on publication and professional ethics. The magazine is free and independent of its owner, SULF – the Swedish Association of University Teachers and Researchers.
If you have tips on issues that you think we should write about, you are welcome to contact us at You can remain anonymous if you wish.